<<Prev Rule

Texas Administrative Code

Next Rule>>
TITLE 43TRANSPORTATION
PART 1TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
CHAPTER 27TOLL PROJECTS
SUBCHAPTER ACOMPREHENSIVE DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENTS
RULE §27.8Conflict of Interest and Ethics Policies

(a) Purpose. This section prescribes ethical standards of conduct applicable to private entities, including consultants and subconsultants, participating in the department's comprehensive development agreement program. A private entity's failure to comply with these standards of conduct may result in the private entity's preclusion from participation in a project or sanctions being imposed under §27.9 of this subchapter (relating to Sanctions).

(b) Gifts and benefits. A proposer, developer, consultant, or subconsultant participating in the comprehensive development agreement program, or an affiliate of any of those entities, may not offer, give, or agree to give a gift or benefit to a member of the commission or to a department employee whose work for the department includes the performance of procurement services relating to a project under this subchapter, or who participates in the administration of a comprehensive development agreement. Notwithstanding this prohibition, a consultant or subconsultant (unless a member of a proposer or developer team, if authorized under subsection (c) of this section) may offer, give, or agree to give a token item that does not exceed an estimated value of $25 (excluding cash, checks, stocks, bonds, or similar items), where the item is distributed generally as a normal means of advertising.

(c) Conflicts of interest.

  (1) Purpose. This subsection prescribes department policy on conflicts of interest relating to consultants and subconsultants participating in the comprehensive development agreement program, and thereby:

    (A) protects the integrity and fairness of the program and all procurements carried out by the department as part of the program;

    (B) avoids circumstances where a consultant, proposer, or developer obtains, or appears to obtain, an unfair competitive advantage as a result of work performed by a consultant or subconsultant;

    (C) provides guidance to private entities so they may assess, and make informed business decisions concerning their participation in the program; and

    (D) protects the department's interests and confidential and sensitive project-specific and programmatic information.

  (2) Applicability. This subsection applies to all comprehensive development agreement projects undertaken by the department. This subsection applies to consultants and subconsultants, and to individual employees of consultants and subconsultants who participated in the performance of services for the department. A reference in this subsection to a consultant or subconsultant also means individual employees of a consultant or subconsultant who participated in the performance of services for the department. To the extent that the department has previously consented in writing to a consultant's or subconsultant's performance of services that are in conflict with this subsection, participation on a proposer team as an equity owner or team member, acting as a consultant or subconsultant to a proposer, or having a financial interest in a proposer or an equity owner or team member of a proposer, this subsection does not modify or alter the prior consent. The foregoing does not prevent, however, the application of this subsection to the consultant or subconsultant for other projects, including taking into account the performance of services on the project for which consent was obtained. This subsection may by extension prohibit or restrict the ability of a proposer to have a consultant or subconsultant participate on the proposer team as an equity owner or team member, act as a consultant or subconsultant to the proposer, or have a financial interest in the proposer or an equity owner or team member of the proposer.

  (3) Period in which a conflict of interest applies. If a determination is made under this subsection that the performance of services by a consultant or subconsultant raises a conflict of interest, the resulting prohibition or restriction provided in this subsection continues:

    (A) for the private entity until the date the performance of services ends and all work product prepared by the entity and other information and data provided to the entity in the performance of services is publicly available; and

    (B) for an individual that is an employee of or was employed by the consultant or subconsultant and who participated in the performance of services for the department:

      (i) until five years after the date the performance of services ends for those projects for which the individual was materially involved in providing services to the department; and

      (ii) until one year from the date the performance of services ends for projects for which the individual was not materially involved in providing services to the department.

  (4) Application to new firm. If a conflict of interest is determined to apply to an individual pursuant to paragraph (3)(B) of this subsection, the conflict of interest and prohibition with respect to the individual will not apply to the individual's new place of employment. If the new employer is otherwise eligible to perform consultant services, the new employer will remain eligible despite the employment of the individual. This paragraph does not apply to an individual employed by an affiliate of its previous employer, and the conflict of interest and prohibition with respect to the individual will apply to such affiliate.

  (5) Federal requirements. For federal-aid projects, the department must comply with the Federal Highway Administration's organizational conflict of interest regulations (found in 23 CFR §636.116). The requirements of this subsection do not limit, modify, or otherwise alter the effect of those regulations, and will be applied consistent with those regulations.

  (6) General conflict of interest standards. Except as provided in paragraph (7) of this subsection, no consultant providing consultant services to the department with respect to a comprehensive development agreement project may be a proposer or participate as an equity owner, team member, consultant, or subconsultant of or to a proposer for that project, or have a financial interest in any of the foregoing entities with respect to that project. Except as provided in paragraph (8) of this subsection, a consultant performing consultant services for a comprehensive development agreement project will not be prohibited from participating on a different comprehensive development agreement project as a proposer or participating as an equity owner, team member, consultant, or subconsultant of or to a proposer for the different project, or having a financial interest in any of the foregoing entities with respect to the different project.

  (7) Providing services for the same project. A consultant that is actively providing preliminary engineering and architectural services to the department with respect to a comprehensive development agreement project, or that performed and completed environmental or traffic and revenue services for a comprehensive development agreement project, may be a proposer or participate as an equity owner, team member, consultant, or subconsultant of or to a proposer for the same project, or have a financial interest in any of the foregoing entities with respect to that project, provided:

    (A) with respect to a consultant providing preliminary engineering and architectural services, all work product prepared by the consultant and other information and data provided to the consultant in the performance of services is made available to all proposers prior to the issuance of the request for proposals for that project; or

    (B) the executive director issues a written determination under paragraph (9) of this subsection that:

      (i) the consultant will not, or in the case of the previous performance of consultant services did not, have access to or obtain knowledge of confidential or sensitive information, procedures, policies and processes that could provide an unfair competitive advantage with respect to the procurement for that project;

      (ii) the data and information provided to the consultant in the performance of the consultant services is either irrelevant to the procurement for that project or is available on an equal and timely basis to all proposers;

      (iii) the work products from the consultant incorporated into or relevant to the procurement for that project are generally available on an equal and timely basis to all proposers;

      (iv) with respect to environmental services, a record of decision or finding of no significant impact has been issued for the project; and

      (v) with respect to traffic and revenue services, there will be no impact on the project's plan of finance, including the ability to obtain and close funding and potential sources of funding.

Cont'd...

Next Page

Link to Texas Secretary of State Home Page | link to Texas Register home page | link to Texas Administrative Code home page | link to Open Meetings home page