<<Prev Rule

Texas Administrative Code

Next Rule>>
TITLE 43TRANSPORTATION
PART 1TEXAS DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION
CHAPTER 9CONTRACT AND GRANT MANAGEMENT
SUBCHAPTER AGENERAL
RULE §9.6Contract Claim Procedure for Comprehensive Development Agreements and Certain Design-Build Contracts

  (3) The executive director's issuance of a final order following a contested case hearing is a purely ministerial act, and that if by inaction the executive director does not issue a final order within the time frame established by the CDA or design-build contract, then a final order in a form recommended by the administrative law judge shall be deemed to be automatically issued.

  (4) As allowed by Government Code, §2001.144 and §2001.145, an order issued by the executive director after a contested case hearing is final on the date issued and no motion for rehearing is required to appeal the final order.

  (5) An executive director's order remanding a dispute to a disputes board, or an executive director's order implementing a disputes board decision following a contested case hearing before SOAH, are subject to judicial review under Government Code, Chapter 2001, under the substantial evidence rule. Review is limited to whether disputes board error occurred.

(k) Other department rules on a contested case hearing.

  (1) The parties may agree in the CDA or design-build contract to adopt, modify or not follow procedural provisions, deadlines, evidentiary rules, and any other matters set out in Chapter 1, Subchapter E of this title (relating to Procedures in Contested Cases).

  (2) In the event of any conflict or difference between the procedures set out in this section or a CDA or design-build contract, and in Chapter 1, Subchapter E, of this title, the procedures in this section or the CDA or design-build contract shall govern with respect to any proceeding before SOAH.

  (3) In the event of an appeal to SOAH of a disputes board decision:

    (A) the department shall present a copy of this section to SOAH as a written statement of applicable rules or policies, under Government Code, §2001.058(c); and

    (B) the parties shall request that the administrative law judge modify and supplement SOAH contested case procedures as necessary or appropriate, and consider this section, consistent with 1 TAC §155.3 (relating to Application and Construction of this Chapter).

    (C) the parties shall provide the administrative law judge with a stipulation that the substantive provisions, scope of review, and procedural provisions of this section and the CDA or design-build contract shall apply to and govern the contested case proceeding before SOAH, consistent with 1 TAC §155.417 (relating to Stipulations).

(l) Mandamus relief. Nothing in this section shall restrict a developer's or design-build contractor's rights to seek mandamus relief pursuant to Government Code, §22.002(c) if the executive director fails to perform one or more of the ministerial acts set out in this section and included in the CDA or design-build contract as a ministerial act, or any other act specified in the CDA or design-build contract as a ministerial act.

(m) Confidential information.

  (1) The parties may agree that, with respect to the mandatory informal dispute resolution process required under subsection (d)(2) of this section, communications between the parties to resolve a dispute, and all documents and other written materials furnished to a party or exchanged between the parties during any such informal resolution procedure, shall be considered confidential and not subject to disclosure by either party.

  (2) The parties may agree that with respect to a proceeding before the disputes board, an administrative hearing before an administrative law judge, or a judicial proceeding in court, either or both parties may request a protective order to prohibit disclosure to third persons of information that the party believes is a trade secret, proprietary, or otherwise entitled to confidentiality under applicable law.


Source Note: The provisions of this §9.6 adopted to be effective December 7, 2006, 31 TexReg 9749; amended to be effective September 15, 2011, 36 TexReg 5948; amended to be effective September 20, 2012, 37 TexReg 7299

Previous Page

Link to Texas Secretary of State Home Page | link to Texas Register home page | link to Texas Administrative Code home page | link to Open Meetings home page