Texas Register

TITLE 34 PUBLIC FINANCE
PART 1COMPTROLLER OF PUBLIC ACCOUNTS
CHAPTER 3TAX ADMINISTRATION
SUBCHAPTER VFRANCHISE TAX
RULE §3.591Margin: Apportionment
ISSUE 11/13/2020
ACTION Proposed
Preamble Texas Admin Code Rule

     (C)Gross receipts from the sale of digital property (computer programs and any content in digital format that is either protected by copyright law or no longer protected by copyright law solely due to the passage of time) that is transferred by fixed physical media are sourced as the sale of tangible personal property under paragraph (29) of this subsection.

     (D)Gross receipts from lease of digital property that is transferred by fixed physical media are sourced as the leasing of tangible personal property under paragraph (14)(B) of this subsection.

     (E)Gross receipts from the sale or lease of digital property that is transferred by means other than by fixed physical media are sourced as the sale of intangible property under paragraph (21)(B) of this subsection.

     (F)Gross receipts from the delivery of digital property as a service are sourced under paragraph (26) of this subsection, unless otherwise provided in this subsection.

     (G)Gross receipts from the delivery of digital property as part of an internet hosting service are sourced as internet hosting receipts under paragraph (13) of this subsection.

     (H)Gross receipts from the use (as opposed to the sale or licensing) of digital property are sourced under paragraph (21)(A) of this subsection.

     (I)Example 1. Movie Studio produces a copyrighted movie in digital format and successively sells the theatrical rights to Movie Theater Chain Company, the broadcast rights to Cable Company, the internet streaming rights to Internet Company A, the internet rental rights to Internet Company B, the digital versatile disc (DVD) sale rights to DVD Company, DVD rental rights to Kiosk Company, and the permanent download sale rights to Download Company. In each instance, Movie Studio's receipts are from the right to use its copyrighted digital property and sourced to where the copyright is used under paragraph (21)(A) of this subsection. Movie Theater Chain Company receipts from ticket sales are from the sale of a service and sourced to the audience location under paragraph (26)(A)(i) of this subsection. Cable Company subscription receipts from broadcasting the movie are from the sale of a service and sourced to the audience location under paragraph (26)(A)(i) of this subsection. Internet Company A's subscription receipts for its streaming service using its website are from an internet hosting service and sourced to the location of the customer under paragraph (13) of this subsection. Internet Company B's receipts from the rental (access for a limited time) of the movie using the company's website are from an internet hosting service and sourced to the location of the customer under paragraph (13) of this subsection. DVD Company's receipts from the sale of DVDs are from the sale of tangible personal property and sourced under paragraph (29). Kiosk Company's receipts from the rental of DVDs are from the rental of property and sourced to the location of the property under paragraph (14). Download Company's receipts from the sale of permanent downloads of the movie are from the sale intangibles and sourced to the location of payor under paragraph (21)(B) of this subsection.

     (J)Example 2. Software Company designs bookkeeping software for personal use. Software Company licenses the software to Computer Company to include in the software sold with its computers. Software Company sells digital versatile discs (DVDs) of the bookkeeping software to Retail Company for resale to end users. Software Company sells downloads of its bookkeeping software directly to end users. Software Company sells an on-line version of its bookkeeping software in which end users can enter and store data on-line using the Software Company's website for a periodic fee. Software Company receipts from licensing the software to Computer Company are from the use of its digital product and sourced to the location of use under paragraph (21)(A) of this subsection. Computer Company's receipts from the sale of computers with pre-loaded software are from the sale of tangible personal property and sourced under paragraph (29) of this subsection. Software Company's receipts from the sale of DVDs to Retail Company are from the sale of tangible personal property and sourced under paragraph (29) of this subsection. Software Company's receipts from the sale of downloads to end users are from the sale of intangible property and sourced to the location of payor under paragraph (21)(B) of this subsection. Software Company's receipts from the sale of its on-line version are from the sale of an internet hosting service and sourced to the location of the customer under paragraph (13) of this subsection.

  (4)Condemnation. Gross receipts [Revenues ] from condemnation [that result from the taking] of property are sourced [gross receipts that are apportioned based on] to the location of the property condemned.

  (5)Debt forgiveness. If a creditor releases any part of a debt, then the amount that the creditor forgives is a gross receipts that is sourced [apportioned] to the legal domicile of the creditor.

  (6)Debt retirement. Gross receipts [Revenues ] from the retirement of a taxable entity's own indebtedness, such as through the taxable entity's purchase of its own bonds at a discount, [are gross receipts that] are sourced [ apportioned] to the taxable entity's legal domicile. The indebtedness is treated as an investment in the determination of the amount of gross receipts.

   [(7)Deemed sales of assets under Internal Revenue Code, §338. Amounts that are deemed to have been received by the target taxable entity are treated as sales of assets by the target taxable entity, and are apportioned according to rules that otherwise apply to sales of such assets under Tax Code, Chapter 171, or this section. For the purposes of this paragraph, the purchaser of the target's stock is considered the purchaser of the assets.]

  (7)[(8)] Dividends[, and/ or interest].

    (A)Dividends that are recognized as a reduction of the taxpayer's basis in stock of a taxable entity for federal income tax purposes are not gross receipts. Dividends that exceed the taxpayer's basis for federal income tax purposes that are recognized as a capital gain are treated as dividends for apportionment purposes.

    (B)The following are excluded from Texas gross receipts and gross receipts from an entity's entire business [ everywhere]:

      (i)dividends from a subsidiary, associate, or affiliated taxable entity that does not transact a substantial portion of its business or regularly maintain a substantial portion of its assets in the United States;

      (ii)Form 1120, Schedule [schedule] C special deductions that are excluded from total revenue; and

      (iii)dividends [and/or interest] on federal obligations that are excluded from total revenue.[;]

       [(iv)interest that is exempt from federal income tax.]

    (C)Dividends [and/or interest] that are received from a corporation or other sources are sourced [ apportioned] to the location [legal domicile] of the payor.

    (D)Dividends [and/or interest that are] received from a national bank are sourced [apportioned] to Texas if the bank's principal place of business is located in Texas. Dividends [and/or interest that are] received from a bank that is organized under the Texas Banking Code are sourced [ apportioned] to Texas.

     [(E)A banking corporation may exclude from its Texas gross receipts interest that is earned on federal funds and interest that is earned on securities that are sold under an agreement to repurchase and that are held in a correspondent bank that is domiciled in Texas, but the banking corporation must include the interest in its gross receipts everywhere.]

  (8)[(9)] Exchanges of property. Exchanges of property are included in gross receipts to the extent that the exchange is recognized as a taxable transaction for federal income tax purposes. Such exchange must be included in gross receipts based on the gross exchange value, unless otherwise required under this section.

  (9)[(10)] Federal enclave. Gross receipts [All revenues] from a taxable entity's sales, services, leases, or other business activities that are transacted on a federal enclave that is located in Texas are sourced to Texas [receipts], unless otherwise excepted by this section.

   (10)Financial derivatives. Gross receipts from the settlement of financial derivatives contracts, including hedges, options, swaps, futures, and forward contracts, and other risk management transactions are sourced to the location of the payor.

  (11)Insurance proceeds.

    (A)Business interruption insurance proceeds are gross receipts when the proceeds are intended to replace lost profits. Such receipts are Texas gross receipts when [apportioned to] the location [legal domicile] of the payor is in Texas [of the proceeds].

    (B)Gross receipts [Revenues] from fire and casualty insurance proceeds are sourced [apportioned ] to the location of the damaged or destroyed property.

   (12)Interest.

    (A)Except as provided in subparagraph (B) of this paragraph, interest received is sourced to the location of the payor.

    (B)Interest received from a national bank is a Texas gross receipt if the bank's principal place of business is located in Texas. Interest received from a bank that is organized under the Texas Banking Code is a Texas gross receipt.

    (C)The following are excluded from Texas gross receipts and gross receipts from an entity's entire business:

      (i)interest on federal obligations that is excluded from total revenue; and

      (ii)interest that is exempt from federal income tax.

    (D)A banking corporation may exclude from its Texas gross receipts interest that is earned on federal funds and interest that is earned on securities that are sold under an agreement to repurchase and that are held in a correspondent bank that is domiciled in Texas, but the banking corporation must include the interest in its gross receipts from an entity's entire business.

  (13)[(12)] Internet hosting service. [access fee. A fee that is charged to obtain access to the World Wide Web in Texas is a Texas gross receipt.] For reports originally due on or after January 1, 2014, receipts from Internet hosting are Texas gross receipts if the customer is located in Texas.

     (A)Internet hosting service means providing to an unrelated user access over the Internet to computer services using property that is owned or leased and managed by the provider and on which the user may store or process the user's own data or use software that is owned, licensed, or leased by the user or provider.

     (B)Internet hosting includes real-time, nearly real-time, and on-demand access over the Internet to computer services such as:

      (i)data storage and retrieval;

      (ii)video gaming;

      (iii)database search services;

      (iv)entertainment streaming services;

      (v)processing of data; and

      (vi)marketplace provider services.

     (C)Internet hosting does not include:

      (i)telecommunications service;

      (ii)cable television service;

      (iii)Internet connectivity service;

      (iv)Internet advertising service; or

      (v)Internet access solely to download digital content for storage and use on the customer's computer or other electronic device.

     (D)The purchase of access over the Internet to computer services is distinguished from the purchase or lease of computer hardware or digital property by taking into account all relevant factors, the relevance of which may vary depending upon the circumstances. Some relevant factors indicating the purchase of access to a computer service rather than the purchase or lease of computer hardware or digital property include:

      (i)the customer is not in physical possession of the property;

      (ii)the customer does not control the property, beyond the customer's network access and use of the property;

      (iii)the provider has the right to determine the specific property used in the transaction and replace such property with comparable property;

      (iv)the property is a component of an integrated operation in which the provider has other responsibilities, including ensuring the property is maintained and updated;

      (v)the customer does not have a significant economic or possessory interest in the property;

      (vi)the provider bears any risk of substantially diminished receipts or substantially increased expenditures if there is nonperformance under the contract;

      (vii)the provider uses the property concurrently to provide significant services to entities unrelated to the customer;

      (viii)the provider's fee is primarily based on a measure of work performed or the level of the customer's use rather than the mere passage of time; and

      (ix)the total contract price substantially exceeds the rental value of the property for the contract period.

     (E)The customer location is determined by the physical location where the purchaser or the purchaser's designee consumes the service. The location should be determined in good faith using the most reasonable method under the circumstances, considering the information reasonably available. Receipts from some services may be sourced to multiple customer locations or to multiple customers. Locations that may be reasonable under the circumstances include the customer's principal place of business, the customer's business unit that is using the computer services, the delivery addresses for individual units of service provided to the customer, the primary place or places of consumption by the customer, the service address of the customer, the billing address of the customer, or a combination of methods. Examples:

      (i)An individual purchases access to a dating application. The most reasonable customer location for consumption of the service may be the billing address of the individual in the absence of information regarding the individual's physical address.

      (ii)A benefactor purchases access to a computer service for a charitable organization. The customer is the purchaser's designee for consuming the service - the charitable organization. The most reasonable customer location for consumption of the service may be the physical address of the charitable organization.

      (iii)An intermediary purchases access to a computer service for resale to a third party. The customer is purchaser's designee for consuming the service - the third party. The most reasonable customer location for consumption of the service may be the physical location of the third party, if known.

      (iv)A law firm purchases access to a database search program for attorneys in multiple offices. The customers are the purchaser's designees for consuming the service - its attorneys. The most reasonable customer locations for consumption of the service may be physical addresses of each office, with the access fee sourced proportionately based on the number of attorneys in each office.

      (v)A retailer with multiple sales outlets purchases access to point of sales software that reports to the retailer's central office. The most reasonable customer locations for consumption of the service may be the physical addresses of the central office and each designated point of sale, with the access fee sourced proportionately between the central office and each designated point of sale.

      (vi)A retailer with multiple sales outlets purchases access to federal income tax preparation software. The most reasonable customer location for consumption of the service may be the principal place of business of the retailer.

      (vii)An individual pays a fee to an Internet ride-sharing service connecting the individual with a driver at a particular location. The most reasonable customer location for consumption of the service may be the physical address of rendezvous point for the ride.

  (14)[(13)] Leases and subleases.

    (A)Gross receipts [Revenues] from the lease, [or] sublease, [(or ] rental, or subrental[)] of real property are sourced [apportioned] to the location of the property.

    (B)Gross receipts [Revenues] from the lease, [or] sublease, [(or ] rental, or subrental[)] of tangible personal property are sourced [apportioned] to the location of the property. If the property is used both inside and outside Texas, then lease payments are sourced [apportioned] based on the number of days that the tangible personal property was used in Texas divided by the number of days that the tangible personal property was used everywhere. If the amount [of revenue that is] due under the lease is based on mileage, then the lease payments are sourced [apportioned] based on the number of miles in Texas divided by the number of miles everywhere.

    (C)If a lump sum is charged for the lease, sublease, rental, or subrental of more than one item of [leased or subleased (or rented or subrented)] property, and the items are [that is] located both inside and outside Texas, the lump-sum is sourced to Texas [then the allocation of such revenue is] based on a ratio of the fair rental value of the items located in Texas[ each item of property] to the fair value of the items located outside of Texas.

    (D)Gross receipts [Revenues] from the lease, [or] sublease, [(or ] rental, or subrental[)] of a vessel that engages in commerce are sourced [apportioned] to Texas based on the number of days that the vessel is engaged in commerce in Texas waters divided by the number of days that the vessel is engaged in commerce everywhere.

    (E)Gross receipts from [If] a lease, sublease, rental, or subrental of real property or tangible personal property that is treated as a sale for federal income tax purposes[, then the receipts from the transaction] are sourced [apportioned] in the same manner as a sale. Any portion of the payments that the contracting parties designate as interest is sourced as provided in paragraph (12) of this subsection, concerning interest [receipts].

  (15)[(14)] Litigation awards. Litigation [Revenues that are realized from litigation] awards are gross receipts that are sourced [apportioned] to the location [legal domicile] of the payor [of the proceeds]; however, if the litigation awards are intended to replace receipts for which another [apportionment] rule [is] provided in this section applies, then the gross receipts are sourced [apportionment must be made] in accordance with that rule. For example, if a taxable entity sues a Delaware corporation to recover on a sale of goods delivered to a Texas location, then a judgment for the amount of that sale would not convert the receipts from Texas gross receipts to Delaware receipts. See subsection (f) of this section, for the sourcing [apportionment] of receipts from judgments, compromises, or settlements that relate to natural gas production.

  (16)[(15)] Loan servicing [of real property].

    (A)Gross receipts [Receipts] from [the] servicing [of] loans secured by real property are sourced [apportioned] to the location of the collateral real property that secures the loan being serviced.

     (B)Gross receipts from servicing loans that are not secured by real property are sourced as provided in paragraph (26) of this subsection, concerning services.

  (17)[(16)] Loans and securities treated as inventory of the seller.

    (A)Gross proceeds from the sale of [If] a loan or security [is] treated as inventory of the seller for federal income tax purposes are included in gross receipts even though the tax basis is not included in total revenue under §3.587(e)(4) of this title. Securities and loans held for investment or risk management purposes are not inventory. Gross receipts from the sale of a loan or security treated as inventory of the seller are sourced to the location of the payor as provided in paragraph (25) of this subsection, concerning securities. See paragraph (2) of this subsection, concerning capital assets and investments, or paragraph (10) of this subsection, concerning financial derivatives, for the treatment of gains and losses from sales of loans and securities not treated as inventory of the seller. [, the gross proceeds of the sale of that loan or security are considered gross receipts.]

    (B)If [For reports originally due on or after January 1, 2010, if] a lending institution categorizes a loan or security as "Securities Available for Sale" or "Trading Securities" under Financial Accounting Standard No. 115, the gross proceeds of the sale of that loan or security are considered gross receipts. In this subparagraph, "Financial Accounting Standard No. 115" means the Financial Accounting Standard No. 115 in effect as of January 1, 2009, not including any changes made after that date.

  (18)[(17)] Membership or enrollment fees paid for access to benefits. Membership or enrollment fees paid for access to benefits are [should be considered] gross receipts from the sale of an intangible asset and are sourced [ apportioned] to the location [legal domicile] of the payor.

  (19)[(18)] Mixed transactions. If a transaction involves elements of both a sale of tangible personal property and a service, but no documentation exists to show separate charges for the tangible personal property [sale] and service elements, then the comptroller may determine the amounts that are allocable to each element based on fair values or on any available evidence.

  (20)[(19)] Net distributive income. The net distributive income or loss from a passive entity that is included in total revenue is sourced [apportioned ] to the principal place of business of the passive entity.

   [(20)Newspapers or magazines. All advertising revenues of a newspaper or magazine, including those revenues derived from out-of-state advertisements, are apportioned to Texas based on the number of newspapers or magazines distributed in Texas. All other receipts must be apportioned in accordance with the apportionment rules otherwise set out in this section. For example, receipts from sales of newspapers or magazines are to be apportioned based on paragraph (29) of this subsection.]

  (21)Patents, copyrights, and other intangible assets [rights].

    (A)Gross receipts [Receipts ]from the use of intangible assets [intangibles].

      (i)Revenues from a patent royalty are included in Texas receipts to the extent that the patent is utilized in production, fabrication, manufacturing, or other processing in Texas.

      (ii)Revenues from a copyright royalty are included in Texas receipts to the extent that the copyright is utilized in printing or other publication in Texas.

      (iii)Gross receipts [Revenues] that the owner of a patent, copyrighted material, trademark, franchise, or license receives from licensing the use of the patent, copyrighted material, trademark, franchise, or license are sourced to [included as] Texas [receipts] to the extent the patent, copyrighted material, trademark, franchise or license is used in Texas.

      (iv)Royalties from an affiliated taxable entity that does not transact a substantial portion of its business or regularly maintain a substantial portion of its assets in the United States are excluded from Texas gross receipts and gross receipts from an entity's entire business [everywhere].

Cont'd...

Next Page Previous Page

Link to Texas Secretary of State Home Page | link to Texas Register home page | link to Texas Administrative Code home page | link to Open Meetings home page